Archive | Politics RSS feed for this section

Amish People Aren’t Autistic Because They Aren’t Vaccinated?

3 Dec

I remember when I was a kid, how important science was in education, and we understood that the scientific method helped us to understand and explain phenomena. If it was backed up by enough evidence, it became a scientific law, such as the law of gravity, though even scientific laws can be “broken.”

People are understandably upset about autism, especially since no one is able to figure out what causes it. So we look for patterns and try to piece it together. This is an anecdotal article about Amish people that claims that only three Amish children were ever vaccinated, and of those, two of them developed autism. I understand the strong desire to explain things, and when things are unexplained, then people want to develop conspiracy theories, but the truth of the matter is without any actual documented data to back it up, you can’t make any conclusions about the Amish as a people and their apparent (at least in this article) lack of autism.

I am posting about this because I am passionate about science and understanding why things work, and every form of research I’ve read indicates there is no connection between vaccinations and autism. I know that there is a similar thought about going gluten-free to reduce the effects of autism, yet there is no science to back that up, either.

I hope that people don’t stop vaccinating their kids because we have already seen the resurgence of whooping cough as a result of this practice. I would hate to see polio and other diseases come back, out of fear that these vaccines allegedly cause autism.

John McCain politicizes IBS

8 Feb

Superbowl is traditionally one of those times where people toss nutrition out the window. It’s a day for snacks, bbq, beer, and hanging out with your friends.

John McCain

Senator John McCain (R) of Arizona

It’s usually not a time for politicians to get political, or to make light of legitimate health concerns. However, Senator John McCain (R) of Arizona took the opportunity on Fox News last Thursday to get in a jab at the government for spending money on a Superbowl half time ad about the census and conflated that with what he thinks is irresponsible spending on Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) research.

Said McCain February 3, 2010 on Fox: “We spend a couple million dollars on irritable bowel syndrome, and we spend a couple of million dollars on an ad in the Super Bowl Sunday, and we continue the practices that infuriate our citizenry because they’re hurting so badly,” to Greta Van Susteren. (source: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,584772,00.html)

McCain objected to this back on December 12, 2009 with regard to the Health Reform act being considered currently by Congress. Said McCain: “$665,000 for, I’m not making this one up, for the Cedar Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles California for equipment and supplies for the institute for Irritable Bowel Syndrome research. <pause> Now, I have a lot of comments on them on that issue, but I’ll just pass so not to violate the rules of the Senate.” (source: http://www.prweb.com/releases/2009/12/prweb3337674.htm)

First of all, $665,000 is not “a couple million dollars.” And second of all, if you research IBS on the internet, you’ll find that it affects anywhere between 10-20% of people in America and that “Absenteeism and presenteeism associated with IBS symptoms have been estimated to cost as much as $20 billion each year, and have been attributed to more work days missed and reduced work productivity.” That’s a lot of Americans who are “hurting so badly” from IBS. (source: http://www.chsinternational.com/Resources%5C2009.06.Constipation.IBS.WPAI.DDW.pdf)

I’m guessing McCain doesn’t suffer from IBS himself, or know anyone close to him who does, because this is a very frustrating condition which makes many of its sufferers very sick to the point where they have to structure their lives around their symptoms. This includes following a rigorous diet in order to stave off or control their symptoms. And neither doctors nor scientists know why this condition occurs, or how to prevent it from happening.

I find it frustrating that mainstream politics is being used to reduce empathy for widespread health conditions and would like to see more compassion for those who suffer on a daily basis from illness. I hope disparaging comments like those from McCain do not set understanding of IBS back; because it’s not a punchline, it’s a legitimate health condition, and its sufferers are real people.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.